Via Credible.com’s Website
Insurance can be boring, but companies have come up with ways to be memorable and entertaining. Geico’s ad campaigns and the characters they’ve created have made it one of the most well-known companies in the business, but its insurance products are far from whimsical.
With coverage options available in all 50 states, Geico has a broad reach, and it offers some of the more generous discount programs, especially for federal government employees. The company takes a leading spot in our overview of the best cheap car insurance providers.
Pros
Coverage available in all 50 states
Wide range of discounts available
Below-average insurance cost
Cons
Local agent availability is limited
Some recent negative review scores
About Geico
Geico has been in business for almost 90 years and has grown into a national car insurance company with coverage options for vehicles, homeowners insurance, boats, and more. While it is now open to any potential customers, Geico started as the Government Employees Insurance Company, and it still offers significant discounts for federal employees today.
The company’s insurance products include a wide range of options, but Geico does not offer guaranteed asset protection coverage, or GAP, which is an important insurance product for people with auto financing.
Features and Benefits
Geico’s insurance services look a lot like those of its competitors’, but there are a few key differences to be aware of. One major difference is its pricing, which is typically lower than the national average. That said, the company’s rates don’t undercut USAA’s which are generally among the lowest in the industry for those who qualify.
- Geico has one of the best discount programs in the industry
- Insurance available in all 50 states and Washington D.C.
- Geico’s local agent network is limited
- Geico’s rates are often less expensive than those of its closest rivals
- Rates are often higher for drivers with blemishes on their records
Geico Reviews: Editorial Rating
Trusted Company Reviews Rating Score for Geico: 9.8
We gave Geico a strong score due to its generous discount programs, strong customer service ratings, and long list of coverage options. While it’s not perfect, the company has a strong track record, and it has accumulated more positive reviews than negative ones. Other companies offer stronger discounts in some areas, and some have more positive reviews, including State Farm.
| Local Agents | 300 agents nationwide |
| Discounts | Multiple, including federal employees, multiple policies, and more |
| Pricing | Generally below the national average car insurance rates |
| Convenience and Customer Service | Above-average customer service, though some complain about claims resolution speed |
Why We Like It
It might be possible to find a cheaper rate with a local carrier or other insurance company, but Geico’s customer service ratings and wide range of insurance products make it one of the easier companies to recommend.
It has a strong online presence, and the company offers several services in its app, including filing a claim and policy information. Customers may be eligible for one of its extensive discount programs, which include multiple policy discounts, federal employee incentives, and more. It doesn’t always provide the absolute cheapest car insurance rates, but on average its prices are better than most.
What We Don’t Like
Despite its generally positive reviews, Geico falls short in a few key areas. It doesn’t offer GAP insurance, which is a fairly common product that can be vitally important to some drivers. Its network of local agents is also quite limited compared to State Farm and other companies, which can be frustrating for people who like high-touch customer service or who prefer personalized interactions.
Additionally, Geico’s usually affordable rates can become the opposite for drivers with “dings” on their records, such as a DUI, speeding tickets, or at-fault accidents.
Geico Car Insurance Reviews
Geico has received a large number of positive reviews, but there are several negative marks to discuss. Many customers complain about the company’s claims resolution process, with several saying they were handed off between multiple agents before moving forward. Others say the process was slow, noting that communication with the company can be difficult at times.
Additionally, a notable chunk of the complaints revolve around pricing, with some saying Geico’s rates change unexpectedly or that customers discovered that they did not have the coverage they thought they were paying for.
On the other hand, many customers say Geico’s agents were very helpful with problem resolution and answering questions. Many praise the company’s app and website, saying they are simple to use and offer robust services.
People also note that Geico’s price match and overall pricing are more favorable than others. The company has also received fewer National Association of Insurance Companies (NAIC) complaints. J.D. Power has also rated the company highly for service.
Who Is Geico Best For?
Geico is a mainstream insurance company with coverage options for almost any driver and good customer satisfaction. The company is a great option for people who don’t qualify for USAA’s coverage and want to save a little money over the national average. Its claims processing and customer service could use some work, but the company is generally well-regarded.
AAA Car Insurance Vs. Geico
Both AAA and Geico are well-known insurance providers with strong reputations and nationwide availability, but they differ in several key areas. AAA is often associated with roadside assistance and membership perks, while Geico is known for its competitive pricing and tech-forward tools.
Geico typically offers lower premiums on average and provides a highly rated mobile app for managing policies, filing claims, and contacting support. On the other hand, AAA may offer more personalized service through its regional clubs and often includes unique benefits for members. When comparing AAA car insurance vs. Geico, it’s important to weigh price against service, perks, and convenience to find the best fit for your needs.
| Feature | AAA | Geico |
| App | Yes, roadside assistance, claims, other services | Yes, claims, customer service, more |
| Availability | All 50 states, Puerto Rico, Washington, D.C. | All 50 states, Washington, D.C. |
| Average Price | $2,293 for full coverage | $1,730 for full coverage |
| Customer Support | Above average, 24/7 support | Above average, 24/7 support |
Geico Alternatives
Geico stands out for its affordability and digital-first convenience, making it a popular choice for cost-conscious drivers who prefer to manage their policies online. However, it’s not always the best fit for people who value personal service or need broader coverage options. If you’re comparing quotes or looking for something different, here are a few other top-rated alternatives from our overview of the best cheap car insurance companies:
- State Farm: Best for personal service and wide coverage options through local agents.
- Lemonade: Best for tech-savvy drivers who prefer fully digital experiences and AI-driven claims.
- USAA: Best for military families and veterans, offering top-tier customer satisfaction and competitive rates.
- Auto-Owners: Best for personalized coverage and claims satisfaction through independent agents.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Geico Cheaper Than Progressive?
Does Geico Pay Its Claims?
Does Geico Refuse Claims?
Source
Logo image source: geico.com
After earning an MBA, Chris began writing about tech and finance as part of his work as a bank analyst and consultant. Wanting to pursue his first love in life, Chris jumped ship and turned his focus to the automotive industry, first as a freelance writer for Forbes, J.D. Power, The Drive, and U.S. News & World Report, before starting YourTestDriver.com and the America on the Road Radio Show. Chris brings more than ten years of experience in product reviews, in-depth analyses, and news, and has been recognized as a significant contributor in building the future of the automotive media field.
Chris Teague
Last Updated: August 7, 2025
Editorial Reviews
Must Reads
Best Egg vs LendingClub
When comparing Best Egg vs LendingClub, the difference between the two comes down to specialization versus wider product availability. Best Egg is a streamlined personal loan lender built primarily for borrowers with fair to excellent credit who want predictable loan...
Best Egg vs Upstart
Best Egg vs Upstart When comparing Best Egg vs Upstart, the key difference comes down to underwriting philosophy and borrower fit. Best Egg generally serves borrowers with fair to good credit who may be more comfortable with traditional credit evaluation. Upstart, by...
Should I Buy a Car or House First?
Should I buy a car or house first? The Short Answer: Buying a house first is usually the smarter financial move. In most cases, buying a house before a car is the better long-term financial decision. Homes can build equity and potentially increase in value over time,...
How Much Money Should I Save Before Buying a House?
The Short Answer: How Much Money Should I Save Before Buying a House? Saving money for a home is mostly about your down payment, but it also includes closing costs and a financial cushion after you move in. Equifax (a major credit bureau) has recommended saving 25% to...
LendingTree Vs LendingClub
LendingTree Vs LendingClub LendingTree and LendingClub both provide access to personal loans, but they operate very differently. One functions as a lending marketplace, while the other is a direct lender and digital bank. Understanding that distinction is essential...
AmONE Vs LendingTree
When comparing AmONE vs LendingTree, the real question isn’t just which platform is more or less legitimate. It’s which marketplace structure better fits your needs. Both companies operate as financial product marketplaces, connecting borrowers with lenders offering...
Credible Vs LendingTree
Credible vs LendingTree, the real question is this: Do you want a streamlined personal loan marketplace, or a broader financial comparison platform with credit tools built in? While both companies let you compare multiple loan offers with only a soft credit check,...
How Does a HELOC Work?
If you’re a homeowner who needs access to funds, a Home Equity Line of Credit, or HELOC, can be a flexible option based on your home’s equity. Unlike traditional loans, it allows you to borrow only what you need over time. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau...
Are Federal Tax Refunds Taxable?
A tax refund is the government giving you back your taxable income if you paid too much throughout the year. So federal tax refunds are not taxable; it’s yours to keep. However, there's an important exception that trips up many taxpayers, and it mainly involves state...
6 Common Budgeting Mistakes to Avoid
If budgeting feels harder than it should, you’re not alone. Many people struggle not because they lack discipline, but because they run into the same common budgeting mistakes over and over again. At Trusted Company Reviews, we review personal finance tools and...
Social Links
