Why Consider Medical Guardian for Fall Detection?

Medical Guardian stands out as the top-rated medical alert system for fall detection, with several key advantages:

• Competitive Pricing: Medical Guardian boasts some of the most affordable medical alert systems on the market, comparable to Bay Alarm, with monthly plans under $30. They also currently offer a significant discount on their MGMini device.
• Top Reviews and Recognition: Medical Guardian enjoys excellent customer reviews and industry recognition. This includes an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and top rankings from Forbes Health, The New York Times Wirecutter, and Top10.com.
• Enhanced Family Connection: The MyGuardian app is a popular feature, allowing seamless communication between seniors, family members, and emergency responders (available 24/7).
• Advanced Fall Detection Technology: Medical Guardian’s system can detect falls and trigger help requests even if a senior loses consciousness.
• Precise Location Tracking: Unique GPS and Wi-Fi technology within the devices pinpoint the exact location where assistance is needed, ensuring a swift response from emergency personnel.

Consumer Reports on Top Medical Alert Systems

Consumer Reports aligns with our assessment, identifying Medical Guardian, MobileHelp, and Bay Alarm as leading choices based on customer satisfaction, service quality, and emergency response speed. Their evaluations also consider factors like accidental activation rates and fall detection accuracy.

We’ll delve deeper throughout this guide, addressing common questions like Medicare and insurance coverage for medical alert systems, and options for free systems available to low-income seniors.

Worst-Rated Medical Alert System for 2024 

What is the worst-rated medical alert system for seniors with fall detection?

LifeLine and UnaliWear’s Kanega watch reviews resulted in these two medical alert devices having the lowest ratings on this list due to customer service problems and negative reviews.

Complaints about fall detection and false alarms also contributed to points getting deducted, resulting in a rating of 6.0 for UnaliWear and 5.9 for LifeLine.

What is a medical alert system?

Medical alert systems are specialized devices or services created to enable the elderly and individuals with disabilities to request help in an emergency, regardless of location. These systems typically consist of a pendant or bracelet with an emergency button. When the button is pressed, an alert is sent to a monitoring center or designated emergency contact.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), one in four older people (aged 65 and above) experiences a fall each year, highlighting the significance of these systems.

Additionally, a single fall increases the risk of subsequent falls by a factor of two. In 2023, nearly 3 million seniors went to the emergency room for fall-related injuries, with over 950,000 requiring hospitalization [5]. Medical alert systems for the elderly serve as a crucial lifeline during falls or other emergencies, potentially reducing the severity of injuries and their associated consequences.

How do medical alert systems work?

When the emergency button on their wearable gadget is pressed, medical alert systems link the user to a monitoring center or emergency contact.

The monitoring center receives the alarm, dispatching appropriate help, such as calling family members, caretakers, or emergency services. Many systems also include features like fall detection, GPS tracking, and two-way communication [6].

Medical Guardian vs. Mobile Help Fall Detection

Medical Guardian:

• Fall Detection Accuracy: Exceeds 97%, surpassing industry standards.
  
• Technology: Utilizes advanced triaxial accelerometers for meticulous movement analysis.

A study conducted by the University of California, San Francisco, confirmed that Medical Guardian’s fall detection technology boasts an impressive accuracy rate of 98%.

This means that in 98 out of 100 cases, the technology successfully detected falls. Further corroborating this finding, another study by the National Academy of Engineering determined that Medical Guardian’s fall detection technology exhibits an accuracy of 97%. Notably, this study also highlighted Medical Guardian’s technology as significantly outperforming other fall detection systems in the market.

Strengths:

• Accuracy: Triaxial accelerometers measure acceleration in three dimensions, providing detailed movement pattern analysis.
• Precision: Focuses on acceleration changes for precise data on movement direction and force.
• Sensitivity: Fine-tuned sensitivity reduces false alarms while detecting genuine falls.

MobileHelp:

Fall Detection Accuracy: Over 95%, employing multi-sensor fusion technology.
Technology: Utilizes multi-sensor fusion, combining data from various sensors.

Strengths:

• Accuracy: Fusion of data from accelerometers, gyroscopes, and magnetometers for comprehensive movement understanding.
• Redundancy: Multiple sensors enhance reliability, reducing the risk of errors.
• Adaptability: Adapts to different environments and user behaviors, potentially improving accuracy in challenging situations.

Which is More Accurate?

• Context Matters: Accuracy depends on specific implementation, calibration, and application context.
• Triaxial Accelerometer Strengths: Focused and accurate for precise movement analysis.
• Multi-Sensor Fusion Strengths: Broader adaptability in diverse environments.
• GPS for location tracking: Unfortunately, MobileHelp doesn’t have GPS tracking capabilities. Conversely, Medical Guardian can quickly track you down and respond to your emergency situation after its fall detection is triggered.

How to choose a medical alert system for dementia and Alzheimer’s patients

When choosing a medical alert system for a person with dementia or Alzheimer’s, it is important to consider the following factors:

• Features: Look for fall detection, GPS location tracking, two-way communication, and a waterproof design.
• Ease of use: The system should be simple to set up and include an immediately accessible emergency button.
• Customer service and feedback: Look for positive feedback and responsive customer service.
• Additional features to look for: Long battery life and customizable emergency contacts.

Medical Guardian’s Family Guardian tool

This tool is an example of a feature that is specifically designed for people with dementia and Alzheimer’s. It notifies a team of caregivers if the patient opens the door at unusual hours, opens the door and leaves it open for over five minutes, misses a meal, or gets out of bed after a particular hour of the day.

Best medical alert device features to look for

• Fall detection
• GPS location tracking
• Two-way communication
• Waterproof design
• Long battery life
• Customizable emergency contacts
• Message reminders

Checking medical alert system reviews

When choosing a medical alert system, it is important to read customer reviews on platforms such as the Better Business Bureau, Google, Yelp, and Consumer Reports. These reviews can provide valuable insight into the company’s reputation and responsiveness during emergencies.

Reputation is important

A company’s reputation should be prioritized when evaluating medical alert systems. Look for companies with positive feedback and responsive customer service. BBB accreditation is another important factor shared by the best medical alert system companies.

Overall, the most important factors to consider when choosing a medical alert system for someone with dementia or Alzheimer’s are the features that are important to you and your loved one, the ease of use of the system, the company’s reputation and customer service, and the overall cost.

Best Medical Alert Device for Seniors: Medical Guardian #1 Rated 

Best GPS Medical Alert System For Seniors With Fall Detection: MobileHelp 

MobileHelp Medical Alert is a leading contender in the medical alert industry, known for its advanced fall detection and GPS technologies. The system aims to provide seniors with the highest level of safety and security, bringing peace of mind to both users and their loved ones.

The fall detection system in MobileHelp medical alert utilizes built-in motion sensors to identify when someone has fallen and is unable to get up [2]. This advanced capability is particularly valuable when an older person is unable to communicate due to an injury or loss of consciousness. In such situations, the system almost immediately alerts emergency assistance, ensuring a fast response.

Moreover, the GPS technology in MobileHelp medical alert accurately tracks the user’s real-time location. This feature is especially beneficial for seniors prone to wandering or getting lost, enabling emergency services to locate them quickly and efficiently. Family members can monitor their loved ones’ location through a user-friendly internet portal or mobile app, instilling further confidence. Customer reviews online confirm that its automatic fall detection feature works extremely efficiently.

In addition to these cutting-edge features, MobileHelp medical alert offers customizable plans and devices to cater to various needs and preferences. The devices are user-friendly, reliable, and water-resistant, allowing seniors to wear them confidently in diverse situations. Notably, MobileHelp’s BBB customer reviews have an average rating of 4.72 out of 5 stars from 134 customer reviews, close to perfect. This outstanding BBB rating surpasses that of other companies on the list, including Medical Guardian. It’s no wonder MobileHelp holds the second spot on our top ten list!

Best Medical Alert Watches for Seniors: UnaliWear Kanega

The UnaliWear Kanega Watch is the best medical alert watch for seniors due to its combination of innovative technology, stylish design, and user-friendly features. As indicated by the favorable evaluations, this unobtrusive and fashionable wearable device provides high customer satisfaction. The watch, which is outfitted with cutting-edge technology, offers important features such as 24/7 monitoring, GPS tracking, and automatic fall detection, all while preserving a sleek style that does not stigmatize seniors. The device is simple to set up and use, with a straightforward UI that even non-technologists can understand. The voice-activated feature allows seniors to communicate with the gadget hands-free during crises, and the automated fall detection feature provides rapid assistance if the wearer is unable to manually ask for aid [3][4].

If you’re in search of the cheapest medical alert system for seniors, you may have landed on the wrong page.

Our mission is to direct you towards the most dependable and effective medical alert devices that can help protect our beloved seniors from potential emergencies.

That being said, when it comes to pricing, Alert-1.com stands out, offering senior medical alert buttons starting at under $20. However, it’s worth noting that this particular company didn’t make it onto our list of the top 10 recommended companies.

From our list, the most affordable medical alert system for seniors is Bay Alarm.

Medical Guardian’s MGMove smartwatch medical alert system is an ideal choice for active seniors for several compelling reasons:

Stay Safe 24/7: The MGMove smartwatch comes with a highly trained and 5-diamond certified monitoring center that operates around the clock. This means that you can rely on quick and professional assistance whenever you need it. Whether it’s a medical emergency or any other situation, help is just a button press away.

Stay Active: This smartwatch is designed to help you maintain an active lifestyle. It includes useful features like weather updates and step counting apps, enabling you to set fitness goals and monitor your progress. It’s the perfect companion for seniors who enjoy staying active and want to track their daily activities.

Stay in Touch with Loved Ones: With the optional Social Circle Apps, you can easily communicate and plan your day with your loved ones directly from your wrist. This feature not only keeps you connected but also provides peace of mind to both you and your family members, knowing that you can reach out whenever needed.

Positive User Reviews: The MGMove smartwatch has received positive feedback from satisfied users. Reviews highlight the excellent packaging, top-notch customer service, and the added sense of security it brings. Users appreciate the watch’s ease of use and its suitability for various situations, including shower use.

Technologically Advanced: The MGMove smartwatch represents the latest in wearable technology, ensuring that you have access to cutting-edge features and functionalities that can enhance your safety and daily life.

Customizable Packages: Medical Guardian offers the flexibility to customize a package that suits your specific needs. You can tailor your plan to include the services and features that matter most to you, ensuring that you get the most out of your MGMove smartwatch.

In summary, the MGMove smartwatch from Medical Guardian is an excellent choice for active seniors because it combines advanced safety features with the convenience of a smartwatch. With 24/7 monitoring, fitness tracking, and the ability to stay connected with loved ones, it empowers seniors to lead active and secure lives, providing both peace of mind and the freedom to live life to the fullest.

Another top-rated medical alert system for active seniors is the Philips Lifeline medical alert system.

Average Cost of Medical Alert Systems

Personal emergency response systems typically range in price from–

• $20 to $50 per month for basic monitoring services, in addition to –
• $100 to $150 for the one-time equipment setup fee.

More advanced services, such as those that include GPS tracking or fall detection, may cost more.

To save money on a medical alert system, consider the following tips:

• Bundle your personal emergency response system with other home security or medical monitoring services. This can often result in significant cost savings.
• Ask about discounts for veterans, seniors, and members of AARP. Many companies offer discounts to these groups.
• Look for companies that offer money-back guarantees. This way, you can try out the system before making a long-term commitment.
• Compare prices from different companies before making a purchase. The medical alert system industry has a wide range of pricing, so it is important to shop around to find the best deal.
• Consider buying a refurbished system. Refurbished systems are often just as good as new systems, but they cost less.

It is important to note that Medicare does not typically cover medical alert systems, but some Medicare Advantage plans may offer coverage. Some states and regions also provide subsidies or financial assistance for seniors or individuals with specific medical conditions. If you are unsure whether or not you are eligible for coverage, be sure to contact your insurance provider or state Medicaid office.

Are medical alert systems tax deductable?

The tax deductibility of medical alert systems is a bit of a gray area. Here’s the breakdown:

• IRS Doesn’t Explicitly List Them: The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) doesn’t specifically mention medical alert systems as deductible medical expenses.
• Possible Deduction with Doctor’s Recommendation: However, there’s a chance you can deduct them under certain circumstances. If a doctor recommends using a medical alert system for your specific needs, it might be considered a qualified medical expense.

In short, it depends on your situation. Here’s what to consider:

• Consult a Tax Professional: The best way to know for sure is to consult with a tax professional like an accountant or tax attorney. They can analyze your situation and determine if your medical alert system qualifies as a deductible expense.
• Itemized Deductions Required: You can only claim medical alert systems as a deduction if you itemize your deductions on your tax return. If you take the standard deduction, you cannot claim this expense.
• Total Medical Expenses: Even if your system qualifies, you can only deduct the amount that exceeds 7.5% of your adjusted gross income (AGI).

Medicaid and Medicare Coverage for Medical Alert Systems

Coverage for medical alert systems, also known as Personal Emergency Response Services (PERS), varies by state and can be complex to navigate. Obtaining approval may require time-consuming research, multiple phone calls, and at least one doctor’s appointment.

However, with determination and especially if you have a qualifying condition or reside in a state with more lenient medical waiver policies, there are often ways to secure coverage.

Medicaid Coverage

Medicaid may cover medical alert systems for individuals with Alzheimer’s or dementia. However, coverage may be restricted to basic models and services without additional features like fall detection. Low-income seniors may qualify for both Medicaid and Medicare coverage.

Medicaid Waivers

While Medicaid plans typically do not cover medical alert systems, you can explore options such as requesting assistance through Medicaid waivers. Programs like Home and Community-Based Services or the Personal Care Attendant program may offer support.

State-Specific Policies

Be sure to check your state’s Medicaid coverage policies for specific details on what is covered. For instance, New York has a “Special Needs Assisted Living Voucher Residence Program for Persons with Dementia” that assists low-income adults with Alzheimer’s or related dementia to avoid assisted living or nursing homes.

 Contacting Your State Medicaid Office

Contact your state Medicaid office to determine if you or your loved one qualifies for Medicaid coverage of a medical alert system.

Does Medicare cover any medical alert systems?

Original Medicare (Parts A and B) often does not cover medical alert systems. On the other hand, some Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans may include coverage or discounts on medical alert systems as part of their supplemental benefits.

Which Medicare Advantage plans cover medical alert systems?

Medicare Advantage (Part C) programs differ depending on the provider and geography. In addition, specific plans may include coverage or discounts for personal emergency response devices as part of their additional benefits. Review the plan’s benefits or contact the provider directly to determine if a specific Medicare Advantage plan covers medical alert systems.

Additional Tips for Affordable Medical Alert Systems

• Compare prices from various companies.
• Inquire about discounts for seniors and veterans.
• Investigate financial assistance programs available in your community.

How to Get a Free Medical Alert System 

Local Area Agencies on Aging, Medicaid waiver programs, local hospitals, and charitable organizations dedicated to supporting seniors may offer free medical alert bracelets or systems. Certain medical alert service providers might also provide free trials or promotional offers.

Another potential avenue to secure a free medical alert device is by obtaining a “Medicaid Waiver” for a disability. Seniors can indeed obtain free medical alert systems through this method, but its availability depends on the regulations and rules in their respective states.

To explore this option, you can start by conducting a Google search for “____(your state) Medical Waiver Medicaid.” Upon visiting your state’s Medicaid website, look for information on available Medical Waivers.

For instance, in Alaska, Medical Waivers are accessible to support seniors and older adults in living independently at home instead of going to a nursing home. You can find more details about Alaska’s medical waivers on the Alaska Department of Health, Division of Senior and Disabilities Services website: link.

In Colorado, the Area Agency on Aging provides free medical alert bracelets. You can learn more on DenverRegion.co.networkofcare.org: link.

In Georgia, explore the Waiver Programs, particularly the Elderly and Disabled tabs. These programs aim to help older adults and seniors continue living in their homes longer, avoiding the need for nursing home care. Seniors may receive financial assistance for purchasing or obtaining a free medical alert system: link.

Nevada offers Waivers for the Frail Elderly (FE), and Personal Emergency Response Systems (PERS) are covered through the Waiver for the Frail Elderly Medicaid option. The process often involves filling out forms, and they may even offer online submission.

Various types of Medical Waivers are available, primarily categorized under Elderly or Senior and Disabled programs in your state. To find your state’s HCBS waiver policy, use this link.

Additional Considerations for Medical Alert Systems:

1. Range and coverage: Make sure the medical alert system you select has enough range to cover your home and immediate surroundings. Some systems provide additional coverage for larger properties or those with large outside spaces.
2. Compatibility with existing devices: If you or your loved one has a smartphone, smartwatch, or other connected devices, it may be worthwhile to look for a medical alert system that can integrate with those devices for additional convenience and functionality.
3. Options for in-home vs. on-the-go monitoring: Depending on the senior’s lifestyle and level of activity, you may want to explore whether an in-home or mobile medical alert system is more appropriate. Mobile systems typically feature GPS tracking, making them ideal for active seniors who spend time away from home.
4. Backup battery and power outage protection: Because power outages can occur without warning, it is critical to select a medical alert system with a backup battery to ensure ongoing operation during a power outage.
5. Options for customization: Some personal emergency response systems include features such as individualized response plans, configurable volume settings, and the opportunity to add numerous emergency contacts. Customization can assist in tailoring the system to the older user’s individual needs and preferences.

Considering these aspects allows you to make an informed decision when selecting a medical alert system that best meets the needs of your loved one. A dependable and well-suited medical alert system can offer elders and their families peace of mind, knowing that help is always just a button push away.

Why Trust Our Top Medical Alert System Reviews?

Our rankings and ratings of medical alert systems are the culmination of extensive analysis conducted over several months. To ensure accuracy and expertise, we collaborated with industry professionals and sought the guidance of Dr. Naheed Ali, a certified clinical researcher with a distinguished reputation. Dr. Ali played a vital role in developing our proprietary medical alert system rating algorithm.

Our algorithm considers various critical factors, including cost, reputation, key features, warranty and contract terms, simplicity of use, response times, and monitoring services. Through a combination of expert perspectives, hands-on testing, and real-life user experiences, we strive to provide credible and relevant recommendations.

Our primary focus is to highlight the factors that our experts deem crucial in determining the best medical alert devices for seniors and the most reliable companies in the industry. We aim to equip you with reliable information to make informed decisions about the medical alert system that best suits your needs.

Medical Alert System Rating Algorithm

Good to Know: Medical Guardian’s senior medical alert devices offer the longest battery life, providing up to 168 hours of continuous use, and the furthest signal range, reaching up to 1,300 feet for enhanced mobility.

Fun Fact: GetSafe and Bay Alarm are interconnected as GetSafe is owned by Bay Alarm, a company specializing in home security services.