The listings featured on this site are from companies from which this site receives compensation. This influences where, how and in what order such listings appear on this site.

x

How We Calculate Rating

Ratings on Trusted Company Reviews are given by experts in that particular industry. Our experts monitor the brand closely and then give the brand a rating which you can trust.

Our rating score is based on 10 Points and a Five-Star shown alongside the score to easily understand the rating.

We frequently update the ratings of all brands so that you don’t choose a brand by their old  ratings.

Choice Home Warranty Reviews

Home » Brands » Choice Home Warranty Reviews
9.4
Virginia Home Warranties
8.6
California Home Warranties

Table of Contents

In this Choice Home Warranty Review, We’ll Cover:

  • Choice Home Warranty Awards, Customer Reviews, Complaints, and BBB Rating.
  • Details and Cost for Choice Home Warranty Plans and Coverage.
  • What to expect for Choice Home Warranty claims process time.
  • Comparison of Choice Home vs. Select Home, Endurance and American Home Shield home warranties.

Is Choice Home Warranty (CHW) the right choice for your home warranty plan in 2023? CHW stands tall as one of the largest companies in the industry, offering wide coverage for all your home appliances and systems. CHW prices are right there in line with the most affordable in the industry, starting at $46.67 per month with low deductibles. CHW’s Basic plan combines coverage for 14 appliances and systems!

Review Choice Home Warranty Awards

  • U.S. News and World Report’s 360 Reviews rated Choice Home Warranty as one of the best home warranty companies for 2022
  • HomeWarrantyReviews.com rated Choice Home Warranty #1 rated in 2020
  • Today’s Homeowner awarded Choice Home Warranty “Best Home Warranty For Seniors,” attributed to their “offering of rates that are below the average for both system and appliance coverage.” This is particularly significant for seniors, as affordable pricing is crucial for older consumers, who often live on fixed or lower incomes and are often associated with social security.
  • Choice Home Warranty ranks in the top 3 at TrustedCompanyReviews.com for Best Home Warranty in California.

With a nationwide network of over 25,000 licensed contractors, help is just a call away whenever needed. There’s a reason why so many consumers trust Choice Home Warranty–size matters when it comes to home warranty plans!

Is Choice Home Warranty best rated? 

The only other home warranty company that comes close to CHW in terms of high customer ratings and reviews is Liberty Home Guard. At the BBB, Liberty Home Guard’s 2,300+ customer reviews have an average rating of 4.56 out of 5 stars. We recommend getting quotes from multiple companies if you’re considering a home warranty plan. Start by comparing Choice Home Warranty and Liberty Home Guard, the two best-rated home warranty companies. See Liberty Home Guard Plans Here, the #1 Rated Home Warranty Provider!


300x250 Covered Home Repairs

What sets them apart?

Choice Home Warranty (CHW) is licensed in every state it operates in, including in California (CA) but under The Home Service Club of California, Inc. (‘HSCCA’).

licensed home warranty company, choice home warranty

Are there regulatory or licensing-related complaints against CHW?

We couldn’t find any complaints listed against CHW with the California Department of Insurance or other regulatory agencies.

To verify licensing and registration details for CA homeowners visit www.Insurance.CA.Gov.

However, how does CHW stack up against other top-rated home warranty companies? Turn to the Top 4 Best Home Warranty Companies List for 2023.


300x250 Protect Your Home Today

Extend the Life of Your Major Systems and Appliances. AC, Heating, Water Heater, Kitchen & Laundry Appliance and So Much More!

 

 

Choice Home Warranty Reviews

What Is Choice Home Warranty?

New Jersey-based Choice Home Warranty has handled more than 6 million service requests since 2009. Like most home warranty companies, CHW offers different prices and coverage options.

Customers can also choose special add-on options that allow them to cover extra items not included in standard plans. If an appliance, system, or other covered item in your home breaks down, you may be able to save on out-of-pocket repair or replacement costs by having one of CHW’s in-network service providers take care of the issue.
300x250 Covered Home Repairs

Pros

  • Choice Home Warranty offers some of the most affordable monthly plans among home warranty companies. At $85, the Choice Home Warranty service call fee is also on the lower end compared to competitors that go as high as $125 per call.

  • All work is backed by a 60-day guarantee. Choice Home Warranty also offers a rare 90-day guarantee on parts!

  • CHW’s Basic plan covers appliances and systems instead of making you automatically upgrade to get both the way that some home warranty companies do.

  • With coverage available in every state other than Washington, CHW has one of the most comprehensive networks in this industry.

  • The standard response time after filing a service request is four hours. Claims can be made on line 24/7.

  • CHW has a high number of positive customer reviews, which suggests they provide good service.

Cons

  • Choice Home Warranty customers cannot choose their own service providers.

  • Add-on coverage options are pretty skimpy.

  • CHW requires you to pay a deductible before any covered repairs are made.

  • This is not a BBB-accredited company.

  • CHW may try to sell you additional coverage that you may not need.

Choice Home Warranty Review

With pricing starting at just $46.67, Choice Home Warranty is one of the industry’s most affordable home warranty companies. It’s also one of the only warranty providers to cover appliances and home systems across all its plans.

The best home and auto warranty companies can help you save hundreds or even thousands of dollars annually.

How much can a homeowner save with a Choice Home Warranty?

Statistic Value
Average cost of repairs covered by warranty $967.69
Average annual benefit of a home warranty $3,009.68

These numbers are based on the following assumptions:

  • The average lifespan of a home appliance is 13 years.
  • The probability of a home appliance failing in any given year is 68%.
  • The average cost of a home appliance repair is $900.
  • The average cost of a home appliance replacement is $1085.
  • The average annual cost of maintaining a home is $3000.

Is Choice Home Warranty right for you?

  • Your specific needs: What are the appliances and systems in your home that are most likely to need repair? Make sure the CHW plan you choose covers them. Write a list of items that you want covered and verify that these items are covered on the plan you choose.
  • Your budget: How much are you willing to spend on a home warranty? After confirming the plan you desire to purchase, next, confirm that Choice Home Warranty’s price is within your budget.
  • Reviews of CHW and other companies: Compare CHW to other home warranty companies to see which one has the best reputation and coverage for your needs.
  • Get quotes from multiple companies: Don’t just accept the first quote you get. Get quotes from several different companies before making a decision. Liberty Home Guard is top-rated for home warranties in Virginia and California.

Important Facts to Know About Choice Home Warranty Plans: 

  1. What’s the catch?: While the Basic plan includes all home systems, the “got you” part of CHW’s setup is that you’ll still need to jump to the Total plan to cover what many consider the three most important appliances in your home. While the Basic plan is quite comprehensive compared to some of the thin introductory plans offered by competing companies, the list of appliances and systems offered under this low-cost plan excludes your refrigerator, clothes washer, and clothes dryer.
  2. Coverage Limit Cap: Choice Home Warranty coverage limits cap payouts at $3,000 per covered item. However, some optional covered items are subject to lower thresholds.
  3. Choice Home Warranty puts a strong focus on customer service. CHW accepts claims 24/7 online.
  4. Fast Response Time: According to customer reviews, Choice Home Warranty’s response time is one of the fastest in the industry. With more than 25,000 affiliated contractors on call, CHW can quickly dispatch pros to your home.
  5. Warranties and Guarantees: In addition to offering an impressive 60-day guarantee for workmanship, CHW will back your parts for 90 days.

Does Choice Home Warranty operate in California?

For California residents, Choice Home Warranty (“CHW”) has forged a strategic partnership with the Home Service Club of California, Inc. (“HSCCA”), a Licensed Home Protection Company authorized by the California Department of Insurance.

This partnership seamlessly integrates CHW’s cutting-edge, technology-driven home warranty administrative services with HSCCA’s offerings, resulting in the introduction of technology-enhanced home warranty solutions tailored to the needs of California residents.

Recognizing the increasingly pivotal role of technology in diverse aspects of home management, HSCCA acknowledges CHW’s advanced technological prowess and its remarkable 14-year history of administrative excellence. This recognition underscores the significant advantages this amalgamation brings to the residents of California.

Within California’s borders, service contracts under the CHW brand are issued and delivered by HSCCA, exclusively promoted through the Home Service Club of California Insurance Services, Inc.

It is imperative to highlight that Choice Home Warranties are not procurable for purchase within California, and CHW lacks the requisite licensing from the California Department of Insurance.

Nevertheless, the collaborative efforts of these two entities have propelled their services to secure a place in the coveted “Top 3 Best Home Warranties in California” list for 2023.

Choice Home Warranty Plans and Pricing

Choice Home Warranty Plan 1: Basic Plan:

Starting at $46.67 per month, CHW’s Basic plan combines coverage for 14 appliances and systems in one plan. Under this low-cost plan, homeowners can bundle the following:

  • Heating system
  • Electrical system
  • Plumbing system
  • Plumbing stoppage
  • Water heater
  • Whirlpool bathtub
  • Oven, range, and stove
  • Cooktop
  • Dishwasher
  • Built-in microwave
  • Garbage disposal
  • Ductwork
  • Garage door opener
  • Ceiling and exhaust fans
  • Air conditioning system

Choice Home Warranty Plan 2: Total Plan:

For around $55 per month, the Choice Home Warranty Total plan covers everything in the Basic plan: your refrigerator, air conditioning system, and washer and dryer.

Choice Home Warranty vs. American Home Shield

With monthly rates ranging from $29.99 to $69.99 across its three plans, American Home Shield (AHS) requires customers to pay more for comparable coverage to CHW’s Basic and Total plans.

You’ll need to settle for just plumbing, electrical, heating, and cooling coverage without appliance coverage if you want to get AHS’s lowest price.

While the $69.99 plan is much pricier than CHW’s most expensive one, it offers comprehensive coverage that includes roof leaks.

The last big point is CHW’s 60-day workmanship guarantee versus AHS’s 30-day guarantee. AHS is available in every state other than Alaska.

Choice Home Warranty vs. Select Home Warranty

With plans ranging from $75 to $100, Select Home Warranty (SHW) is the pricier company. SHW also uses a model that offers an appliance-only plan (Gold Care), a systems-only plan (Platinum Care), and a third plan (Bronze Plan) that combines the coverages of both plans.

While SHW’s service fees, ranging from $75 to $100, are reasonable for the industry, they lack the predictability of the Choice Home Warranty deductible, a flat fee of $85 per service call. While SHW matches CHW’s 60-day labor guarantee, it doesn’t offer an equivalent to Choice’s 90-day parts guarantee.

Customers report that SHW requires a little more red tape when it comes to getting maximum payouts on covered items. Before a claim can be processed, SHW asks customers for proof of maintenance. Meanwhile, CHW will only ask for proof of maintenance if a customer chooses to dispute a claim denial.

Choice Home Warranty BBB Complaints and Reviews

When evaluating companies of Choice Home Warranty’s magnitude, it’s essential to consider BBB reviews and complaints in the context of the company’s size.

  • Choice Home Warranty BBB Rating: The company currently holds a “C” rating with the BBB. While it had a “D” rating in early 2023, it has since improved to a “C” rating as several complaints have been resolved or dropped from its record. We believe in this instance, BBB is failing to recognize the size of the company in relation to the number of complaints submitted.
  • Ratio of Complaints to Choice Home Warranty Customers and Service Requests: Choice Home Warranty boasts an impressive success rate of over 99% regarding customer satisfaction, as evidenced by this evaluation metric. The company has handled more than 6,600,000 service requests, with BBB complaints accounting for less than 0.5%.

Choice Home Warranty Complaints

In 2019, the Arizona Attorney General’s Office initiated a consumer fraud lawsuit against Choice Home Warranty. The Attorney General’s office alleged that CHW had made false claims to customers and had collected millions of dollars while imposing unfair payment caps, contract exclusions, and claim denials.

The lawsuit stemmed from customers’ complaints of being left without functional air conditioning during sweltering temperatures after requesting service through their CHW warranties.

It’s important to note that this lawsuit is still pending, and the company has not been proven wrong or guilty.

Choice Home Warranty Reviews on Google

While CHW has gotten into some hot water with lawsuits and a lack of BBB accreditation, real-world users give the company much higher ratings than one might think just by looking at the headlines.

Choice Home Warranty currently stands at 3.6 stars out of 5 based on 14,089 Google reviews. Trustpilot users give the company 3.7 stars out of 5 based on nearly 35,000 reviews.

Most of the negative reviews of CHW are tied to Choice Home Warranty HVAC coverage and Choice Home Warranty electrical coverage. Choice Home Warranty appliance repair reviews tend to be much more positive by comparison.

The big issue with poor Choice Home Warranty reviews and ratings seems to come down to the company’s handling of slow repairs and heavy denials for major systems.

A number of customers have shared that the company can be very slow to approve authorizations for repairs on heating and cooling systems. Others were upset to discover that the technicians dispatched to their homes were not equipped to do the work that needed to be done.

Finally, many reviewers were frustrated by Choice Home Warranty claim denial reasons that made them feel like their contracts misrepresented coverage.

Choice Home Warranty Coverage Details

CHW’s Basic plan covers 14 appliances and systems. This is one of the only companies that includes heating, electrical, and plumbing in the basic tier. While the Basic plan covers most of your home’s appliances, you’ll need to jump up to the Total plan to get your refrigerator, washer and dryer, and air conditioning covered.

CHW also allows you to purchase add-on coverage for specialty items. Optional coverage is available for the following:Extra freezer

  • Second refrigerator
  • Central vacuum
  • Pool and spa
  • Roof leaks
  • Well pump
  • Sump pump
  • Septic system
  • Septic tank pumping

Choice Home Warranty has some pretty hefty exclusion policies. Under the Choice Home Warranty pre-existing conditions clause, all regularly covered items are excluded from coverage if they have pre-existing issues. Coverage also excludes the following:

  • Cosmetic items on appliances. This includes handles, knobs, and doors
  • Maintenance services for air conditioning
  • Sediment buildup in water heaters
  • Reservoir tanks in water heaters
  • Fire damage
  • Storm damage
  • Theft

Full repair or replacement costs aren’t necessarily covered on covered items. CHW policies cap payouts for covered items at $3,000 per item per 12-month contract cycle. This cost includes access, diagnosis, repair, and replacement. Most add-on items are capped at $500 per claim.

Choice Home Warranty Claim Process

CHW customers can log in online to submit new claims 24/7. The online portal also makes tracking a claim’s progress easy. For customers who prefer to call, the claims department can be reached at (888) 373-7924. Choice will send an in-network service provider within 48 hours of receiving a claim. Customers can expect delays when claims are filed outside of normal business hours.

Choice Home Warranty doesn’t make guarantees for turnaround times on getting items repaired or replaced. While they will try to dispatch a tech to your home within 48 hours, the company cannot guarantee that the technicians will have the equipment, materials, or skills needed to take care of the problem on the spot. Your technician may also need to wait for authorization while CHW reviews your claim against what’s covered in your policy. Some customers find that Choice Home Warranty claims process time can stretch out for weeks.

Choice Home Warranty Customer Service and Support

Choice Home Warranty is one of the only home warranty companies to operate a 24/7 call center to help customers get their worries addressed around the clock. The general impression that customers have about CHW’s customer support team is that they are generally very helpful and responsive until there is some kind of hiccup in the claims process. While agents are extremely helpful when activating claims, customers say that they sometimes won’t hear back from reps for days or weeks while authorization is pending.

While claims can be filed online, you’ll need to call the customer service phone number to activate the Choice Home Warranty cancellation process. Customers are free to cancel at any time.

However, your refund will be prorated. CHW will deduct the amount for any services you’ve used. If the dollar amount for the services provided to you prior to your cancellation date is greater than the amount you’ve paid in contract fees, you’ll actually owe CHW money.

There’s also a $50 cancellation fee.

Choice Home Warranty coverage transferability allows you to transfer coverage at any time with no additional fees or penalties.

Choice Home Warranty Contractor Network

CHW’s network of more than 25,000 contractors is one of the largest in the industry. Contractors that provide services for CHW act as independent contractors.

Unfortunately, the company provides very little information regarding how it selects and approves contractors for its networks. This makes verifying Choice Home Warranty contractor quality difficult. We were able to find out that all technicians must meet the minimal requirements of having a current trade license, carrying general liability insurance, and possessing automobile insurance.

Other related products to help homeowners save money:

At TrustedCompanyReviews.com, we look to review products and services that can help people save money. Home warranties are one of those products, right there alongside –

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Choice Home Warranty a ripoff?

Is Choice Home Warranty worth it?

Is Choice Home Warranty worth it, according to customer comments on Reddit?

Choice Home Warranty vs. Landmark Home Warranty – Which plan is best?

How do I buy a home warranty from Choice Home Warranty?

How do I file a claim with Choice Home Warranty?

How long does it take after a claim is made for a technician to come?

Does Choice Home Warranty cover roof leaks?

Does Choice Home Warranty cover mold?

Does Choice Home Warranty cover water damage?

Does Choice Home Warranty cover termites and insects?

Does Choice Home Warranty cover theft?

Does Choice Home Warranty cover damage from trees?

What additional home warranty coverages are offered by Choice Home Warranty?

Does Choice Home Warranty have customer complaints?

Conclusion

Choice Home Warranty Rating Breakdown

Criteria Choice Home Warranty
BBB 4
Customer Reviews 9
Lawsuits and Complaints 7
Cost 9
Coverage–Essential Components 10
Claims Processing Efficiency 10
Customer Support 10
Extra Features 9
Reviewer Opinion 18
Total Points 86

Home Warranty Industry Rating Criteria

Criteria Description Total Possible Points
BBB Rating A+ = 10, A = 9, A- = 8, B+ = 7, B = 6, B- = 5, C = 4, D = 3, E = 2, F = 1, No industry license = 0 1-10
Customer Reviews Average weighted rating across multiple sources, including BBB, Best Company, U.S. News 360 Reviews, Consumer Affairs, Google Reviews, TrustPilot, Investopedia, and MarketWatch. 1-10
Lawsuits and Complaints Complaints and lawsuits, resolution, responsiveness, and client-to-complaint ratio. 1-10
Cost Based on Total Cost, Monthly and Service Fees 1-10
Coverage Points awarded for covering all major home system and appliance components, along with pre-existing conditions. 1-10
Claims Processing Ease of filing claims and efficient claims processing. 1-10
Customer Support Availability of 24/7 support, response time, and friendliness of customer service. 1-10
Extra Features Points for high-quality add-on coverage options. 1-10
Reviewer Opinion Includes the reviewer’s opinion, taking into account time in business, overall customer reviews, financial stability and transparency (as highlighted below) 1-20
Financial Stability A financially stable company is more likely to honor its commitments.
Transparency Is the company transparent about its terms and conditions? (online, through sales and contracts)

Source

Sources:

  1. Arizona Attorney General, Kris Mayes, AG Brnovich Files Consumer Fraud Lawsuit Against Home Warranty Company, https://www.azag.gov/press-release/ag-brnovich-files-consumer-fraud-lawsuit-against-home-warranty-company
  2. Choice Home Warranty BBB Profile Page, https://www.bbb.org/us/nj/edison/profile/home-warranty-plans/choice-home-warranty-0221-90048733
  3. TrustPilot, Choice Home Warranty Reviews, https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.choicehomewarranty.com
  4. Choice Home Warranty website, What’s Covered, https://www.choicehomewarranty.com/whats-covered/
  5. FairShake.com, How to cancel your account with Choice Home Warranty, https://fairshake.com/choice-home-warranty/how-to-cancel/
  6. Home Repair and Remodel, Marshall & Swift L.P, “Average cost of a home system or appliance repair.”
  7. Consumer Expenditure Survey, U.S. Census, “How much homeowners spend on repairs every year”
  8. MSN Real Estate, “Cost to maintain a $300,000 home.”

About Author

Dr. Ali
Scott Dylan Westerlund has been writing about home improvement, repair, and maintenance for almost ten years. In addition to Trusted Company Reviews, he writes for Angi, HomeAdvisor, Today's Homeowner, Homedit, Flyhomes, and HomeLight. You'll find his byline on articles about everything from buying a house and managing rentals to clearing clogged drains and picking the right lumber for your home improvement project. Prior to writing, Scott was an apprentice building contractor and property manager--so he knows how to keep the lights on and the water running.
Dr. Ali

Scott Dylan Westerlund

Last Updated: May 29, 2024

Editorial Reviews

ADT Company Review

Home Security Industry Expert Reviews ADT This ADT review will cover everything you need to know about the company, its products, and the experience you might expect owning them. The company is one of the most well-known and largest in the industry, offering a wide...

Ring Home Security System Review

A 2024 Ring Security System Review (tried and tested) Searching for reviews on Ring home security systems? This Ring security system review will cover everything you need to know about the company, its products, and the experience you might expect owning them. I...

Must Reads

Is 5k Funds Legit?

Is 5kFunds legit? Personal loans can be a great way to fund home projects, consolidate debt, and make other life changes, but you need to be careful to ensure you’re getting the financial products you expect and protect yourself against being taken advantage of. The...

Personal Loan Vs. Personal Line of Credit

Finding personal financing can be a real hassle, but the good news is that there is a range of products available to help you bridge the financial gap. Personal loans and personal lines of credit are two of the most popular, but there are some key differences between...

Is Transform Credit Legit?

Is Transform Credit Legit? Looking for a personal loan but your credit isn’t great? It can be tough to find a lender willing to provide a personal loan. While you can find several lenders, you don’t always know which ones are the best. Transform Credit could be the...

Mobile Help Vs. Medical Guardian

MobileHelp Vs. Medical Guardian Startup Cost Product 1 Product 2 Mobile Help None MobileHelp Classic: $359.40/year MobileHelp Solo: $384.50/year Medical Guardian Up to $199.95 MGMini Pendant: $439.45/year MG Home Classic: $329.45/year (wrist band device) It’s...

Everything You Need to Know About SimpliSafe Home Security

SimpliSafe Home Security offers several bundles that make it easy to outfit a home without sorting through dozens of individual products. Buyers can also build their own bundles and browse add-on devices, so there is some flexibility in the ordering process. The...

Is Cash For Cars Legit?

Cash for cars services are a quick and hassle-free way to sell your vehicle. But is Cash for Cars legit? Explore what Cash for Cars entails, its pros and cons, key things to know, and whether it's worth it. What is Cash for Cars? Cash for Cars offers a straightforward...

Is WorkMoney Legit?

Looking for an easy way to save money on everyday items and more? WorkMoney offers solutions for those trying to reduce their expenses and save more money. But how do you know if WorkMoney is legit? We’ve researched WorkMoney to provide you with the information you...

How to Build Business Credit Fast

Learning how to build business credit fast is less crucial than learning how to build business credit at all. While building any credit, whether personal or business, takes time, there are several steps you can take to help speed up the process somewhat. More...

How To Get a 100K Business Loan

If you're starting a new business or expanding an existing one, we don't have to tell you about the massive number of moving parts involved. Funding the transition is just one part—albeit a big one. As expected, entrepreneurs often spend most of their time honing...

Can I Refinance My Private Student Loan? Learn Options for 2024!

The weight of student loan debt can feel overwhelming, especially for graduates of professional programs like law school and medical school. According to the latest data from the American Bar Association, the average law school graduate owes approximately $130,000 in...

Social Links