The listings featured on this site are from companies from which this site receives compensation. This influences where, how and in what order such listings appear on this site.


How We Calculate Rating

Ratings on Trusted Company Reviews are given by experts in that particular industry. Our experts monitor the brand closely and then give the brand a rating which you can trust.

Our rating score is based on 10 Points and a Five-Star shown alongside the score to easily understand the rating.

We frequently update the ratings of all brands so that you don’t choose a brand by their old  ratings.

Top 5 Queen Mattress Toppers and Brands of 2023

Some of the frontrunners in our best queen mattress topper review this year may surprise you. While there are a vast number of mattress toppers to choose from, picking one simply comes down to your comfort. However, that’s sometimes more challenging than it may sound. Besides brands, numerous types and materials, all with different qualities, exist. That fact is excellent for confusing even the most savvy shoppers.

Below, we discuss the best queen mattress toppers and the best queen mattress topper brands in the business. We chose to focus on the queen mattress toppers. However, each topper brand offers a selection of mattress topper sizes. You’ll likely notice some of them are also in our review of the best mattresses on the market. We’ll also talk about how to choose one, what to look for for your needs, and what makes a mattress topper great. Here are the five best queen mattress toppers for 2023.

Deane Biermeier
DIY and Home Products Expert
9.6 Excellent

Saatva’s queen mattress toppers excel by providing something for everyone looking for comfort and support in a topper.

  • Seven types and styles to choose from
  • Rated 4.77 stars of 5 at the Better Business Bureau
  • A+ BBB grade
  • Costlier than some topper brands
  • 180-day trial period
  • Made of hypoallergenic materials
Read All Reviews
  • Table of Contents
Last Updated: October 25, 2023
Best Overall
9.6 Excellent

  • Offers a coil-spring queen topper
  • Company also offers mattresses and other bedding supplies
  • Large and varied product selection
  • 180-day trial period
  • eco-INSTITUT certified, free of harmful chemicals
  • Best for side and back sleepers
9.5 Excellent

  • 5 models available
  • Gel-infused foam mattress toppers
  • 3 and 4-inch thick models available
  • 90-day trial period
  • machine-washable topper covers
  • Low motion transfer in all models
8.3 Very Good

  • Mattress topper division is known as Mattress Topper
  • Four models available in queen size
  • 30-day trial period
  • 3-year warranties
  • Reasonable prices
  • A+ graded company
8.2 Very Good

  • Single mattress topper style
  • Excellent for side sleepers
  • Works well with any sleep style
  • 3" thick memory foam topper
  • 10-year warranty
  • No product trial period
8.1 Very Good

  • Excellent motion isolation
  • 30-day trial period
  • 5-year warranty
  • A+ BBB grade
  • Single topper product available
  • Available in-store or online

What is a Queen Mattress Topper?

In the 1980s, memory foam became available to consumers in bedding products, including mattresses and mattress toppers. Since then, the mattress topper has evolved from mattress pads and protectors to include the material in its design. This leap forward transformed the versatility of basic bed mattresses.

Queen mattress toppers are simply mattress pads with more robust qualities. They rest on an existing queen mattress to provide extra support and other features. Mattress toppers can completely change the feel of an old mattress. And, while not designed to prolong a mattress’s life, it’s possible to use a topper to rejuvenate the feel of the bed.

Today’s mattress toppers may include layers of memory foam, various cover materials, plush features, and even miniature inner springs for additional support in some models.

Do I Need a Mattress Topper?

While a mattress topper can be a wonderful accessory to improve the feel of your existing bed, using one isn’t necessary in every situation. However, If you struggle with a mattress that’s uncomfortable or has lost its springiness, a mattress topper can certainly improve your sleeping conditions. Remember, though, that even the best mattress toppers aren’t designed to fix a sagging or aged mattress’s problems.

Mattress Pad Vs. Mattress Topper Vs. Mattress Protector

There are several types of queen mattress toppers, pads, and protectors. The three also have big differences despite the common misconception that they’re all pretty much the same.

Mattress Protectors are essentially slip covers that go over a mattress and secure to its edges with straps or pockets. These products are often waterproof and keep liquids and other staining or harmful substances off the mattress. Mattress protectors are commonly used for children’s beds to keep the mattress from getting wet. But they’re helpful in other situations as well.

Mattress Pads are similar to, and the predecessor of, mattress toppers. Mattress pads are generally thinner, single-material foam padding that simply rests on the bed. Some mattress pads include a washable cover, but these products are mostly identifiable by their thin profiles and ability to add an extra layer of comfort. You may be familiar with “egg-crate” style mattress pads that are still commonly used.

Mattress Toppers offer many of the same features that a mattress does. Cooling technology, thick memory foam layers, and even innersprings are available in some models. A mattress topper is distinctive by its inclusion of some type of memory foam and a height of between two and four or more inches.

Types of Mattress Toppers

Queen mattress toppers all share similar qualities in providing an extra layer of comfort to an existing mattress. The comfort they offer comes from using various materials and construction methods. Here are the most common mattress topper types and their benefits.


Memory Foam Mattress Toppers

Memory foam mattress toppers are often perceived as a generic term referring to one of several types of memory foam construction typical of mattress toppers. While that’s partially true, there’s more than one type of memory foam. When talking specifically about a memory foam topper, the subject usually refers to a polyurethane-based material.

Memory foam toppers are excellent for adding a few inches of height to a bed, providing additional support and comfort, and minimizing motion transfer.

Pillowtop Mattress Toppers

A pillowtop mattress topper consists of at least one layer of supportive memory or other foam type underneath a plush padding layer. Pillowtop toppers supplement the support from the mattress below while providing a soft, cozy, and luxurious feeling that you can “sink into.”

Latex Mattress Toppers

Latex foam toppers are similar to memory foam. However, distinct differences are also apparent. Latex foam is made of either natural or synthetic rubber. The toppers provide excellent support by contouring to the sleeper’s body rather than allowing it to simply sink in. Latex provides a natural cooling sensation and can help reduce motion transfer, too. However, memory foam isolates motion somewhat better than latex.

Gel Foam Mattress Toppers

A gel foam mattress topper is a memory foam topper that’s given improved cooling and support properties by adding synthetic gel or gel beads to the memory foam construction recipe. The gel or gel beads create a cooler feel than a standard memory foam without gel.

Down Mattress Toppers

A down mattress topper is just as it sounds. These thick mattress toppers are filled with natural feathers or down. These toppers provide little additional mattress support. However, they add a luxurious, super-plush comfort to a bed.

Wool Mattress Toppers

Wool is another natural product often found in specific types of mattress toppers. Wool toppers offer moderate additional support while being hypoallergenic, naturally wool, and offer a soft, cushiony feel.

Organic Mattress Toppers

Organic mattress toppers are made entirely of organic materials, including cotton, wool, bamboo fibers, and others. Organic mattress toppers can mimic the feeling of nearly any synthetic topper material while offering potential health benefits.

Hybrid Mattress Toppers

Hybrid mattress toppers combine the best of memory or latex foam support with other features, such as innersprings, pillowtop materials, or other elements, to maximize the benefits of both the foam and the added material.

What to Look for in a Queen Mattress Topper

Queen mattress toppers come in a variety of types and styles in the queen size. Some are better than others depending on your sleeping habits, such as whether you sleep on your side, stomach, back, or all three. Many mattress toppers aim to relieve pressure points or change the overall feel of your bed mattress. Here are the elements to look for depending on your sleep style.

Firm Queen Mattress Toppers

While many mattress topper types will, by their nature, make a mattress feel somewhat firmer. A topper designated as firm can provide tons of extra support. Firm toppers are often the go-to solution for easing back pain for stomach sleepers. These toppers can be made of nearly any standard topper material. When choosing your product, look for a firm option in drop-down menus, as they’re seldom the first choice for the larger demographic of side and back sleepers.

Soft Queen Mattress Toppers

Soft mattress toppers are available as down, feather, or wool constructs. However, hybrid toppers often include a plush layer that qualifies as soft while still providing additional support. Not all soft mattress toppers are necessarily plush, though, and some manufacturers offer softer versions of their typical medium or medium-firm offerings. Soft mattress toppers are great for lighter-weight side and back sleepers.

Best Queen Mattress Toppers for Side Sleepers

Side sleepers, or those who tend to sleep on one side or the other rather than on their backs or stomachs, are the largest sleeping demographic. So, the best mattress topper for side sleepers may also be the best topper overall. However, there are some other considerations to account for.

Side sleepers also often require much in the way of pressure point relief and support for their mid-sections. A mattress topper that ticks a lot of boxes for general support may not satisfy all side sleepers’ needs.

If you’re a side sleeper trying to determine the best mattress topper for you, start by looking for a product that offers body contouring and support features like pressure-point relief. Latex foam is often a good choice.

Cooling Mattress Topper

Cooling queen mattress toppers offer a variety of ways to make the topper you’re sleeping on feel less hot than a normal mattress. Cooling attributes are achievable using various cell structures within the foam, breathable fabrics for the covers, or infusing gel into the foam. Cooling mattress toppers can help improve sleeping conditions for those who tend to feel hot during sleeping hours.

Do cooling mattress toppers work?

Two types of cooling queen mattress toppers exist. The first is a topper with built-in cooling properties, such as gel or a perforated cover. The second has an active mechanical system for sending cooled water through tubes in the topper itself. Both work well but achieve the goal quite differently from each other.

Mechanically-cooled toppers can lower the physical temperature of the bed by several degrees, helping to keep you cool all night. Passive cooling toppers that use gels or other methods simply make the topper feel cooler through its cooling effects.

Are Mattress Toppers Worth It?

A mattress topper can revive weakened features of an existing mattress. However, a mattress topper can’t prolong the life of a sagging mattress or one with other problems.

Replacing a mattress that doesn’t work for you can be expensive. If the mattress you’re sleeping on doesn’t suit your needs, a mattress topper can be well worth the investment.

With prices ranging from under $100 to over $600, you can likely find a queen topper that can provide the qualities your mattress can’t for a fraction of the price of a new one.

How to Choose a Queen Mattress Topper

To determine which mattress topper is right for your needs, answering several questions before shopping is essential. Ensure your investment is in a topper that answers the following questions satisfactorily.

1. Is the topper good for my sleeping position or style?
2. What do I expect this mattress topper to improve about my bed?
3. If I suffer from back pain, can this topper help relieve the condition?
4. Is the cover removable and washable?
5. Will the topper also protect my mattress?
6. Does the topper fit securely on my size bed?
7. What is the price of the topper?
8. How long will the topper last, and what is the warranty?
9. How long is the trial period if it has one?
10. Do I need a queen mattress topper or a short queen mattress topper

Short Queen Mattress Topper

A short queen mattress topper shares the same 60-inch width that a queen mattress topper has. However the short queen, also called queen short, is 5 inches shorter than a standard queen mattress. A queen mattress and mattress topper measure 80 inches long, while a short queen or queen short is just 75 inches long. A short queen mattress topper is necessary to function on a short queen mattress, which is common in RVs and boats where an extra five inches make a big difference.


Where Do They Sell Mattress Toppers?

Queen mattress toppers are already a popular item for the bedroom and can be found almost anywhere mattresses are sold. They’re available online through manufacturer, sales, and retail websites. They’re also available in almost any department or big box store, as well as specialty bedding stores and others.

Best Rated Mattress Toppers

To create our list of the top five queen mattress toppers available for the year, we poured through almost two dozen front-running contenders to identify the best. However, some honorable mentions exist that we reviewed but didn’t make our top five.

Below is a list of commonly asked-about categories for mattress toppers. We listed the best individual topper, from our perspective, in each category, whether it made our “best” list or not.

side sleeper image

Best Mattress Topper for Back Pain

Coming out on top in our review and qualifying as the best mattress topper for back pain is the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Topper.

Best Mattress Topper for Side Sleepers

The Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Mattress Topper is the hands-down winner in the best for side sleepers category.

Best Mattress Topper for Hip Pain

The Viscosoft Select High Density offers excellent pressure-point relief that can help ease hip pain. It’s our choice for the best mattress topper for hip pain.

Best Mattress Toppers for College

The SleepOnLatex Pure Green Natural Latex mattress topper is available in sizes that fit a dormitory bed. It offers excellent support, cooling, and pressure point relief in a natural latex topper at a low price to ensure a good night’s sleep before the big exam.

Best Mattress Toppers for Cooling

While there are numerous contenders for the best cooling mattress topper, our pick is Brooklyn Bedding’s 3-inch Titanflex Topper for its cooling properties and reasonable price.

How We Chose the Best Mattress Topper Brands

To determine our top picks for the best mattress toppers for 2023, we evaluated more than 20 of the best-known manufacturers (and some lesser-known ones) and their products, ranked them according to the metrics below, and chose the best one in each of our categories.

Price – We ranked each company’s queen mattress toppers offerings based on the MSRP listings and ignored any current sales or promised discounts.
Warranty – The length and details of each product warranty were ranked, and awarded points for various features and limitations
Trial Period – Many companies offer a money-back trial period for products. The length of these trial periods was included in our rating system.
Product Availability – Ease of purchase and location availability made up our scores for this category
Temperature Regulation Qualities – Products with cooling and other temperature-regulating features scored highly in our review.
Model Options – The quantity and value of each company’s model options counted toward individual company scores.
Overall Reviews – We evaluated rating scores and reviews of queen mattress toppers from experts and consumers to award our overall review points.
Editorial Points – We left a portion of our total points available to reward companies that offered outstanding benefits beyond normal expectations.

The Best Mattress Toppers Reviews

The best queen mattress toppers and brands offer something for everyone. While some of our picks offer smaller selections of queen mattress topper, all of the companies and products we feature are highly rated by consumers and critics alike. Here’s a deeper look at the competitors to help you decide which one is perfect for you.

How We Rated Mattress Toppers

Available Sizes 10 possible points
Price <$100: 10 points

$101 – $200: 8 points

$200 – $299: 7 points

$3+: 6 points

Warranty Details 10+ years: 20 points

5 to 9 years: 16 points

2 to 4 years: 12 points

1 year: 8 points

Trial Period  >364 days: 14 points

100 – 364 days: 12 points

90 – 99 days: 10 points

30 – 89 days 8 points

<30 days: 0 points

Retail Availability Online and Store: 10 points

Store Only: 8 points

Online Only: 8 points

Temperature Regulation Features yes: 5 points

No: 0 points

Model Options and Thicknesses Available Up to 12 points
Overall Consumer Review Data Up to 20 points
Expert Opinion Score Up to 20 points

Best Overall: Saatva

saatva mattress topper image

Saatva Mattress Topper Review

Saatva is a premier mattress manufacturer that’s been in business since 2010. The company enjoys excellent ratings among numerous customer review platforms, including high marks from the Better Business Bureau on all fronts. Saatva offers an excellent selection of mattress toppers to meet nearly any need. Front, side, back, and combination sleepers will all find a comfortable topper solution with Saatva.

About Saatva

Saatva specializes in creating top-of-line mattresses and bedding components. The company also scored highly on our annual best mattresses roundup and rated exceptionally well in our Saatva mattress review.

The company’s Graphite Memory Foam Topper is far and away the most popular among Saatva’s queen mattress topper choices. However, Saatva also offers a host of other bed covers and toppers, including a featherbed-like plush topper, protective covers, and even a topper that incorporates 1-inch micro coil springs into its design.

Saatva Queen Mattress Topper Overview

Saatva offers seven distinct mattress topper options in the queen size—Some with machine-washable protective mattress covers, others with plush featherbed-like elegance or thick memory foam, and hybrid options. 

The company is a leading provider of memory foam and hybrid mattresses. It’s not surprising that the company excels in its offerings of various mattress toppers, covers, and protectors. In business since 2010, Saatva is a highly rated company among consumers. The company rates 4.77 of five stars at the Better Business Bureau, where it also carries an A+ grade.

Saatva Features and Benefits

Saatva mattress toppers come in multiple styles to fit your needs. The Graphite Memory Foam topper is a three-inch thick customer favorite.

  • Seven types of toppers and covers available
  • Rated 4.77 stars of 5 at BBB
  • A+ BBB grade
  • Offers a coil-spring topper
  • More expensive than many competitors
  • Company also offers mattresses and other bedding supplies
  • Large and varied product selection
  • 180-day trial period
  • Free product shipping
  • eco-INSTITUT certified, free of harmful chemicals
  • Hypoallergenic materials and construction
  • Short, 1-year warranty on toppers
  • Best for side and back sleepers
  • Available online and in a few retail locations

Why We Chose Saatva

We chose Saatva as the best overall mattress topper provider because of the company’s commitment to creating something for everyone. Whether you need simple mattress protection or the ultimate in mattress comfort and pressure relief, there’s a Saatva mattress topper product just right for the job.

Pros and Cons


  • Large and varied product selection
  • Highly-rated company
  • 180-day trial period
  • Free product shipping
  • eco-INSTITUT certified, free of harmful chemicals
  • Mattresses and other accessories also available
  • Hypoallergenic materials and construction


  • Costlier than some competitors
  • Short, 1-year warranty on toppers
  • Some complaints of off-gassing from new toppers
  • Not as good for stomach sleepers as other brands
    Only a handful of store locations exist


Saatva Editorial Rating

Trusted Company Reviews Rating Score for Saatva: 9.6

Scoring Criteria Points Awarded
Available Sizes 7
Price 7
Warranty Details 8
Trial Period  12
Retail Availability 8
Temperature Regulation Features 5
Model Options and Thicknesses Available 12
Overall Consumer Review Data 17
Expert Opinion Score 20


Saatva Models

Saatva offers a little something for everyone by providing consumers with their choice of seven different model options.

Model Features Queen Mattress Topper Price
Down Alternative Featherbed Topper Ultra-plush


Certified chemical-free

Down-like fill

Mattress Pad Organic bed cover

Cotton construction

Machine washable

Waterproof Mattress Protector Cotton covering


Machine washable

Graphite Memory Foam Topper Signature topper

3″ thick memory foam

Cooling ability

Limits motion transfer

Micro-Coil Topper 3″ height

Hybrid with micro coils

Cotton cover

High-Density Foam Topper 1.5″ height

Medium feel firmness

Prolongs mattress life

Natural Latex Topper 1.5″ height

Latex construction

Cotton cover



Saatva Queen Mattress Topper Reviews

Including 4.77 of five stars at the BBB and an A+ grade, Saatva also enjoys excellent customer ratings and reviews on many platforms, with scores ranging from 4.5 to 4.8 stars almost everywhere.

saatva mattress topper bbb rating image

Is Saatva Right for You?

Saatva’s wide selection of mattress topper products will surely have something for everyone. However, side and back sleepers will likely find the company’s products more satisfactory than many stomach sleepers.

Customers weighing around 230 pounds or less will find choosing a Saatva mattress topper easy, as most products will accommodate them nicely. The company’s firmer memory foam toppers are likely the best choice for those over that weight.

Saatva Vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Toppers

Saatva provides consumers many model options, while Tempur-Pedic offers just one type in a couple of styles. However, Tempur-Pedic toppers also make it into our best mattress toppers review due to the product’s excellent qualities. While the two companies operate quite differently, they both feature qualities that may appeal to similar demographics.

Feature Saatva Tempur-Pedic 
Trusted Company Reviews Rating 4.8 4.1 
BBB Grade / Rating 4.77 / A+ 1.05 / A+
Queen Price Range $195 – $475 $419 – $479
Warranty 1 year 10 years
Trial Period 180 days None
Retail Availability Mostly online Online and in stores
Temperature Regulation Yes Yes
Model Options 7 2
Reviews Very highly rated Highly rated

Best Value: ViscoSoft

viscosoft queen mattress topper image

ViscoSoft Mattress Topper Review

ViscoSoft products revolve around a single construction theory with slight variations between models. The company’s gel-infused, dense foam construction is part of all five of its offerings. While ViscoSoft, as a company, has suffered some lackluster review scores, its lineup of high-quality mattress toppers fits many consumers’ needs well. A budget-friendly model is also available.

About ViscoSoft

ViscoSoft has been in business since 2007, and despite some weak reviews, the company’s mattress toppers are highly regarded. ViscoSoft offers five mattress topper variations, several of which allow customers to choose between different heights and colors. The products are available for online sale and in select retail locations.

The company’s focus on gel-infused, high-density foam reflects its commitment to providing pressure-point relief and solid support. ViscoSoft claims that its mattress toppers will add new life to an existing old mattress.

ViscoSoft Queen Mattress Topper Overview

Our choice for best value goes to ViscoSoft this year. While the company offers several variations of mattress toppers, its budget-friendly and most popular Select High Density option provides excellent value that won’t break the bank. ViscoSoft focuses on gel-infused, high-density, memory-foam toppers that offer excellent support and breathability. 

ViscoSoft Features and Benefits

Several of ViscoSoft’s five topper options also allow you to choose the thickness that fits you best, and some offer color options, too.

  • 5 models available
  • A budget-friendly models is available
  • Gel-infused foam mattress toppers
  • 3 and 4-inch thick models available
  • 90-day trial period
  • machine-washable topper covers
  • Fast, three-day delivery
  • 5-year product warranty
  • 2 and 3-year extended warranties available for purchase
  • Low motion transfer in all models
  • Add firmness to old mattresses
  • Mattresses also available from company
  • Hypoallergenic material construction
  • B- BBB grade
  • Some low review scores

Why We Chose ViscoSoft

Not only does ViscoSoft offer great options throughout its line of toppers, but the company also offers at least one as a budget-friendly alternative to high-priced products that include features that may not be necessary. For this reason, we chose ViscoSoft as the provider of the best value in mattress toppers.

Pros and Cons


  • 5 models available
  • 90-day trial period
  • Extended damage warranties available
  • 5-year warranty
  • Low motion transfer properties in all models
  • Add firmness to older mattresses
  • 3-day delivery time
  • Mattresses also available from company
  • Hypoallergenic material construction


  • B- BBB grade
  • Some low review scores
  • Toppers vary only slightly between models
  • No low profile mattress pads available
  • Possibly too little support for stomach sleepers
  • Some off-gassing when unboxing product


ViscoSoft Editorial Rating

Trusted Company Reviews Rating Score for ViscoSoft: 4.75

Scoring Criteria Points Awarded
Available Sizes 6
Price 8
Warranty Details 20
Trial Period  10
Retail Availability 10
Temperature Regulation Features 5
Model Options and Thicknesses Available 10
Overall Consumer Review Data 13
Expert Opinion Score 13


ViscoSoft Models

ViscoSoft offers five topper styles, with some providing thickness or color options. Three models offer a queen short or short queen size, common in RVs, that many competitors don’t provide in any models.

Model Features Queen Mattress Topper Price
Select High Density -Choice of 3 or 4-inch thickness

-High-density foam

-Slip-resistant backing

-Available in short queen mattress toppers

Serene Hybrid -Choice of 3 or 4-inch thickness

-18″ deep skirt


-Available in short queen mattress toppers

Active Cooling Copper -Available in two colors

-4″ inches thick foam

-Copper-infused washable cover

Reflex Gel -Budget-friendly model

-Choice of 2 or 3-inch thickness


Select High Density – Infused -3-inches thick

-Gel-infused foam

-Available in short queen mattress toppers



ViscoSoft Mattress Topper Reviews

Despite offering excellent products, finding a review of ViscoSoft is hit or miss, depending on where you look. Reviews often focus on larger and more well-known brands. While most of the company’s reviews are good to excellent—rating four stars or above, some reviewers only award ViscoSoft ratings in the low to mid-3-star range. The BBB grades the company at a B- for inconsistent customer complaint resolutions.

bbb b- rating image

Is ViscoSoft Right for You?

A ViscoSoft mattress topper will appeal mostly to those wishing to revitalize an older mattress and are okay with adding several inches of height to their bed. Also in the company’s lineup is a budget-friendly option that costs just over $100 and provides support similar to more expensive models from both competitors and ViscoSoft itself.

The company’s mattress toppers best suit sleepers weighing less than 230 pounds. However, the firmer offerings can work well for consumers above that weight who sleep primarily on their sides or back.

ViscoSoft Vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Toppers

Both ViscoSoft and Tempur-Pedic focus on providing comfort and support using foam technology. However, ViscoSoft offers several more variations on the theme than Tempur-Pedic does. ViscoSoft also provides a less costly option than much of its competition, including Tempur-Pedic.

In Tempur-Pedic’s favor, though, the company offers a 10-year product warranty to ViscoSoft’s 5-year offerings. Tempur-Pedic doesn’t provide a trial period, however.

Feature ViscoSoft Tempur-Pedic 
Trusted Company Reviews Rating 4.75 4.1 
BBB Grade / Rating No rating / B- 1.05 / A+
Queen Price Range $109.95 – $469.95 $419 – $479
Warranty 5 years 10 years
Trial Period 90 days None
Retail Availability Online and in stores Online and in stores
Temperature Regulation Yes Yes
Model Options 5 2
Reviews Rated well Highly rated

Best Cooling: Brooklyn Bedding

brooklyn bedding queen mattress topper image

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Toppers Review

Brooklyn Bedding operates Mattress Topper offers a line of four toppers that are somewhat customizable to conform to your needs. Each model provides various custom options that differ between models—Some offer comfort level choices while others offer thickness options or your choice of cooling or organic cotton covers.

About Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding began in 2008 as one of a small handful of companies providing direct-to-consumer, bed-in-a-box services to consumers. The company’s division, Mattress Topper, still functions on the same business model but for toppers and accessories instead of mattresses and bed frames. Mattress Topper uses many of the same materials in its toppers as Brooklyn Bedding does in its mattresses.

The company focuses on comfort and support through its varying-density memory foam toppers lineup. Standard bedding sizes, as well as queen short or short queen variations for RV use, are available with some models.

Brooklyn Bedding Queen Mattress Topper Overview

Brooklyn Bedding calls its mattress topper division simply Mattress Topper. Several products, including toppers, mattress protectors, pillows, and more, are available on the company’s website and at select retail locations. Mattress Topper offers four versions of memory foam mattress toppers that vary in thickness and density.

Customers will likely find a combination of topper and options to fit their needs. The company’s few model options provide enough choices to satisfy the needs of many sleeping styles and body types.

Brooklyn Bedding Features and Benefits

Brooklyn Bedding’s Mattress Topper offers several benefits and features in a reasonably priced line of topper products and accessories.

  • Company is known as Mattress Topper brand for its toppers
  • Four models available
  • Short queen models available
  • Free shipping
  • Gel memory foam construction
  • Choice of firmness level on some models
  • 30-day trial period
  • Later topper available
  • 3-year warranties
  • Reasonable prices
  • For sale online and in stores
  • Pillows and mattress protectors also available
  • Choice of thickness on some models
  • Latex model is somewhat pricey
  • A+ BBB grade

Why We Chose Brooklyn Bedding

We chose Brooklyn Bedding’s Mattress Topper toppers as the best option for enjoying cooling qualities while you sleep. While the company has several cooling versions of its products, it also offers a simple organic cotton cover for comfort. The 2.5-LB Gel Swirl Memory Foam Topper provides superior cooling and body contouring for prices starting at under $100 when on sale.

Pros and Cons


  • Multiple custom options for each model
  • A+ graded company
  • Pillows and accessories also available
  • Short queen size option available in some models
  • Reasonable pricing on most models
  • Available online an in stores
  • Free shipping


  • Relatively short 30-day trial period
  • Relatively short 3-year warranties
  • Most expensive model is quite expensive


Brooklyn Bedding Editorial Rating

Trusted Company Reviews Rating Score for Brooklyn Bedding: 4.15

Scoring Criteria Points Awarded
Available Sizes 7
Price 7
Warranty Details 12
Trial Period  8
Retail Availability 9
Temperature Regulation Features 5
Model Options and Thicknesses Available 6
Overall Consumer Review Data 16
Expert Opinion Score 13


Brooklyn Bedding Models

Mattress Topper operated by Brooklyn Bedding offers four topper styles from budget-friendly to luxury.

Model Features Queen Mattress Topper Price
2.5-LB Gel Swirl Memory Foam -Gel memory foam construction,

-Choice of 2 or 3-inch thickness

-Available in plush model

4-LB Memory Foam -Available in queen-short size

-Choose from cooling or organic cover versions

-Choice of 2 or 3-inch thickness

-Plush comfort level available

3″ Titanflex Topper -Contouring foam construction

-Available in queen-short size

-Choose from cooling or organic cover versions

-Choose a soft, medium, or firm comfort level

3″ Talalay Latex Topper -Talalay latex rubber construction

-Available in queen-short size

-Choose from cooling or organic cover versions

-Choose a soft, medium, or firm comfort level



Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Toppers Reviews

Brooklyn Bedding and its counterpart company, Mattress Topper, receive average to high ratings that vary by platform. The company gets almost two stars from the BBB and carries an A+ grade for handling customer inquiries and complaints. While Brooklyn Bedding toppers are mostly reasonably priced, the Talalay Latex model is quite pricey.

queen mattress topper make brooklyn bedding A+ BBB grade image

Is Brooklyn Bedding Right for You?

Offering just four topper models seems like it wouldn’t be enough to please all sleeper types. However, Brooklyn Bedding’s Mattress Topper brand provides customization options for each model in its lineup. Custom choices range from thickness variables to comfort level firmness options. Brooklyn Bedding also offers most of its selection at reasonable prices to appeal to a large demographic.

Brooklyn Bedding Vs. Casper Mattress Toppers

While Casper and Brooklyn Bedding could be an excellent rivalry in the mattress world, Brooklyn Bedding takes the prize, slightly, among mattress toppers in most situations. Slim advantages that Casper may hold over Brooklyn Bedding are price in some cases and having a longer warranty of five years instead of three.

Feature Brooklyn Bedding Casper
Trusted Company Reviews Rating 4.15 4.05
BBB Grade / Rating 1.97 / A+ 1.13 / A+
Queen Price Range $216 – $663.30 $299
Warranty 3 years 5 years
Trial Period 30 days 30 days
Retail Availability Online and in stores Online and in stores
Temperature Regulation Yes Yes
Model Options 4 1
Reviews Highly Rated Rates well


Best for Side Sleepers: Tempur-Pedic

tempurpedic queen mattress topper image

Tempur-Pedic Mattress Toppers Review

Tempur-Pedic offers two variations of a single mattress topper style called the Tempur-Adapt Topper. The two versions include the standard model and the same style with added cooling technology.


The company offers just a single topper style in two variations—One of which provides cooling technology for a slightly higher price. The toppers consist of memory foam materials measuring 3″ inches thick. Tempur-Pedic places a 10-year warranty on its toppers. However, a trial period doesn’t exist.


About Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic is a well-known bed and mattress brand focusing primarily on mattresses. Tempur-Pedic also offers several bedding accessories and various cushions. It’s products are widely available online and in retail stores.

While the company doesn’t offer much in the way of product selection when it comes to toppers, we chose the Tempur-Adapt as the best for side sleepers for its medium-firm feel and support.

Tempur-Pedic Queen Mattress Topper Overview

Tempur-Adapt is Tempur-Pedic’s entry onto our list as the best mattress topper for side sleepers. The Tempur-Adapt’s medium firmness comfort level appeals to some sleep styles, such as back and combination sleepers, but is most likely to please side sleepers. Choosing a Tempur-Pedic mattress topper is simple. Choose from the original version or the same with added cooling technology.

Tempur-Pedic Features and Benefits

Tempur-Adapt from Tempur-Pedic is highly rated despite only offering two variations of a single topper model.
  • Single mattress topper style
  • Excellent for side sleepers
  • Works well with any sleep style
  • 3″ thick memory foam topper
  • 2 versions available
  • Upgrading to cooling technology is reasonably priced
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • 10-year warranty
  • No product trial period
  • Removable and machine washable cover
  • Free shipping
  • Corner straps hold topper in place

Why We Chose Tempur-Pedic

Side sleepers require excellent pressure-point relief and usually enjoy a medium firmness level. Tempur-Pedic offers both of those features in its pair of topper offerings. The company doesn’t spend resources building toppers that are too soft or too firm and only appeal to small audiences. For that, we chose Tempur-Adapt Topper as our best choice for side sleepers.

Pros and Cons


  • Excellent for side sleepers
  • Works well with any sleep style
  • Cooling upgrade is reasonably priced
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • 10-year warranty


  • Just one topper style available
  • No product trial period
  • Low BBB rating score


Tempur-Pedic Editorial Rating

Trusted Company Reviews Rating Score for x company: 4.1
Scoring Criteria Points Awarded
Available Sizes 6
Price 6
Warranty Details 20
Trial Period  0
Retail Availability 10
Temperature Regulation Features 5
Model Options and Thicknesses Available 3
Overall Consumer Review Data 16
Expert Opinion Score 16


Tempur-Pedic Models

Tempur-Adapt makes our list as the best topper for side sleepers. The model is available with or without added cooling technology.

Model Features Queen Mattress Topper Price
Tempur-Adapt 3″ thick memory foam mattress with medium firmness level, 

Stretchable knit cover

Tempur-Adapt + Cooling Tempur-Adapt topper model with added cooling cover $479


Tempur-Pedic Mattress Toppers Reviews

While Tempur-Pedic enjoys numerous high ratings from various professional and consumer review platforms, the company only scores 1.08 of five stars at the BBB. However, it does carry an A+ grade from the Bureau.

tempurpedic bbb score image

Is Tempur-Pedic Right for You?

Tempur-Pedic is a popular brand choice among memory foam mattresses and toppers fans. The company spends most of its resources creating excellent mattresses and accessories. However, the Tempur-Adapt will appeal to many consumers with its medium to medium-firm feel.

Staying away from an overly soft or firm design means the Tempur-Adapt, with or without its cooling cover option, serves side, back, stomach, and combination sleepers well. However, side sleepers will likely find the most benefits.

Tempur-Pedic Vs. Sleep Number Mattress Toppers

Where Tempur-Pedic offers a single style of mattress topper in a couple of variations, Sleep Number offers more options at a lower cost. However, Tempur-Pedic’s focus on comfort and support outweighs Sleep Number’s less intense focus on toppers.

Sleep Number is a world leader in adjustable beds with adjustable firmness levels. So, the company doesn’t have to be concerned much with mattress toppers. Although Sleep Number offers some topper styles, the products focus more on complementing the company’s proprietary mattresses than trying to be a contender as a great mattress topper provider.

Feature Tempur-Pedic Sleep Number 
Trusted Company Reviews Rating 4.1  Not rated
BBB Grade / Rating 1.05 / A+ 4.59 / A+
Queen Price Range $419 – $499 $249.99 –$349.99
Warranty 10 years 10 years
Trial Period None 100 days
Retail Availability Online and in stores Online and in stores
Temperature Regulation Yes No
Model Options 2 2
Reviews Highly rated Highly rated

Best for Motion Isolation: Casper

Casper comfy mattress topper image

Casper Mattress Topper Review

Casper Mattresses offer excellent support, cooling, and motion isolation benefits. Learn more in our Casper mattress review. Casper’s mattress topper, the Comfy Mattress Topper, offers the same features. The company uses polyurethane foam to create its single topper style. The product ranks as our best pick for motion isolation and, by extension, the best for couples.

Casper’s single mattress topper offering rates best for motion isolation in our reviews. The company uses polyurethane foam in its Comfy Mattress Topper, which minimizes motion transfer, making it a great choice for couples. Casper also offers mattresses that pair well with its cooling topper and other accessories for sale online or in stores. There’s more to learn in our Casper mattress review.

About Casper

Casper is a well-known bed-in-a-box, direct-to-consumer outfit primarily offering mattresses and accessories. The company rates well across many professional and consumer review sites and carries an A+ grade with the BBB despite some low rating marks on the platform.

The company offers a single mattress topper. It also offers a couple of options for mattress protectors. The topper comes with a 30-day trial period and a 5-year warranty.

Casper Queen Mattress Topper Overview

Casper offers just one mattress topper model that appeals to many consumers partly because of its ability to minimize motion transfer and provide excellent support features.

Casper Features and Benefits

While Casper’s topper selection is minimal, its features and benefits are easy to see.

  • Excellent motion isolation
  • 30-day trial period
  • 5-year warranty
  • A+ BBB grade
  • Single topper product available
  • Mattresses and accessories are also available
  • Buy in-store or online
  • Perforated cooling cover
  • machine washable cover
  • Reasonably priced

Why We Chose Casper

We chose the Casper Comfy Mattress Topper as the best product in our review for minimizing motion transfer from one side of the bed to the other. This quality is excellent for couples sharing a bed. The topper’s medium-firm feel also appeals to a wide variety of sleep styles and body types—Again making it great for couples.

Pros and Cons


  • Motion isolation is great for couples
  • 5-year warranty
  • A+ BBB grade
  • Cooling tech built-in
  • Mattresses and accessories also available
  • Mattress protectors available
  • Available in-store or online
  • Machine washable cover
  • Reasonable pricing


  • Just a single mattress topper model is available
  • Some low review scores
  • Relatively short 30-day trial period


Casper Editorial Rating

Trusted Company Reviews Rating Score for x company: 4.05

Scoring Criteria Points Awarded
Available Sizes 6
Price 7
Warranty Details 16
Trial Period  8
Retail Availability 10
Temperature Regulation Features 5
Model Options and Thicknesses Available 3
Overall Consumer Review Data 14
Expert Opinion Score 12


Casper Models

Casper offers just one mattress topper product and a couple of options for mattress protectors, including a waterproof version.

Model Features Queen Mattress Topper Price
Comfy Mattress Topper 3″ thick polyurethane memory foam, washable cover with cooling properties $299


Casper Mattress Toppers Reviews

Casper’s mattresses rate highly among many review sites. Its mattress topper does well, too. However, its ratings are slightly lower than the company’s overall average scores. While Casper maintains an A+ grade at the BBB, it suffers a little from low reviews there.

casper queen mattress topper ratings image

Is Casper Right for You?

A Casper mattress topper finds its best audience among side sleepers due to its medium-firm feel. However, the product pairs well with many mattress firmness levels and complements the mattress’ features. This fact means the Comfy Mattress Topper can work well for anyone when combined with the right mattress.

However, Casper’s Comfy Mattress Toppers may be the answer for side sleepers looking for a cool night’s sleep with great support on a reasonably priced topper.

Casper Vs. Novaform Mattress Toppers

Casper and Novaform are both available in stores. However, Novaform toppers are only available through retailers like Costco, Sam’s Club, and others. Although the companies share some traits, such as short trial periods and some low ratings, Casper is more focused on providing luxury-level products than Novaform.

Feature Casper Nectar
Trusted Company Reviews Rating 4.05 Not rated
BBB Grade / Rating 1.12 / A+ Not rated / C
Queen Price Range $299 $99.98 – $209.99
Warranty 5 years 10 years
Trial Period 30 days 30 days
Retail Availability Online and in-store In-store or store websites only
Temperature Regulation Yes No
Model Options 1 9
Reviews Highly rated Rates well 

Frequently Asked Questions

These are some of the most common questions surrounding mattress toppers

Do mattress toppers help back pain?

Relieving minor back pain is one of the common reasons consumers turn to mattress toppers. Whether their current mattress doesn’t provide adequate support or has lost some of its ability to offer comfort, a mattress topper can help reduce some types of mild back pain. For more severe back pain, contact a physician for proper medical advice.

Are egg crate toppers good for your back?

Egg crate-style mattress pads offer some additional support to an existing bed mattress. By extension, the added support can help to relieve some types of minor back pain.

Are gel mattress toppers good for your back?

Gel mattress toppers are primarily designed with cooling features in mind. While the cooling properties can allow for a better night’s sleep, which can often be good for your back, memory foam and latex toppers are typically better suited to providing back support.

Are wool mattress toppers hot?

Wool is a natural insulator—Meaning it reduces the speed at which heat (and cold) transfers from one area to another. Because of this, wool mattress toppers are considered a cool type of topper.

Image Sources: – – – – – –

Want your company or product reviewed by us?

Contact Us